Quantcast
Forum

 

SEARCH THIS BLOG
« Plethora of Minimalism | Main | Travelers 1, Ryanair 0 »
Saturday
Jan222011

One bag Dilemmas--Souvenirs

For those of us who one bag,  there are times when the small of luggage we take can actually cause a problem. I’d like to start a series of discussions going on how each of handles a particular problem.

First ups, souvenirs. Most people buy them and they can very easily add weight and bulk to our one bags. How do people here handle souvenirs and is it still possible to one bag it if you are a shopper?

(BTW, if you have other “one bag dilemma” topics, feel free to post your suggestions in the forum and I will put them on the blog—incrementally.)

(Frank II)

Reader Comments (29)

Ask a friend or relative travelling with you to put your souvenir stash in their checked bag for the trip home?

Seriously, I try to pack my bag only 2/3 full to leave room for purchases and souvenirs. To the point where I tell myself if I really might want to bring that extra item of clothing - I can always buy something when I arrive instead! I have to be strict with myself for it's easy to think "I have a small bag to start and there's still room to spare, might as well fill it!"

I also take a roomy foldable "Pilage" tote bag from Longchamp as a "just in case" bag. This way I can use the tote as my one-bag and if I really must - check my real one-bag (the horror!)....or if I'm able to - carry on both bags. I've done this and pretended the Longchamp tote was my "hand bag".

Here is a link to the Longchamp site, the "Pilage" comes in several sizes, and colours. It folds flat and is easy to take along. It's a little pricey for a spare bag, but sturdy. You can get them with short handles or long to fit over the shoulder.

http://www.longchamp.com/en/bags-tote-bag-women-255.html

http://www.longchamp.com/en/home-e-shopping/home-sur-mesure-usa/sur-mesure-etape-1-561.html

Still, starting from before you leave - the statement "pack half the clothes you think you need, and twice the money." Makes sense!
January 22, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterMaria
Now five trips in to traveling, I've come to a realization it's just more "stuff," so do I really need it. Not much. Remembering that helps .. a bit.

Mostly, be very selective with souvenirs. Maria's note to start with some space does help, too, so when you start collecting you have a place to put it.

The purse I've used on several trips is a mini-messenger bag from LL Bean (I've not seen it since purchasing it in '08). It's about 9x9, so if a souvenir can't fit while I'm out and about, I can't buy it.

My only exception to the size rule has been the occasional t-shirt, and I wear them while on the trip (ie, the useful souvenir).
January 22, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterBetsey
Ship them home.

If shipping is really expensive, it will make you think twice about buying that handmade pottery lamp for Aunt Ethel...
January 22, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterAndyW
True about shipping things home! That helps with bulky or heavy items.

When visiting family in Europe, and thought I would have plenty of space in my bag for the return trip...as most of the packing space was taken up with items they had asked me to bring over for them and I presumed once I handed out the loot - all the more space left for me. However, it goes both ways - they in turn gave me things to bring back home for myself and to bring to family over here too. Like several large hardback coffe-table books! Hence my bringing the spare bag just in case.

For things I purchase for myself when I travel - I am selective, if I can wear them all the better. (scarves, a piece of jewellery) If it's bulky or heavy, perhaps the shop can ship it home for you too. Also, with the internet for shopping - if you really feel you must have it - sometimes it's easier to just order on line and have things shipped home too.
January 22, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterMaria
If I know I will buy something I either take a thin foldable bag along or I leave room in the luggage. The expendable roller is actually good for this situation. Use it as carry-on on the way there and then expand it and check it on the way back. If I use a foldable bag I check it and try to fill it with dirty laundry and the least valuable things I took along.

If I don't have any plans of buying anything there but I still run into a must-have item, I can just as well buy a cheap bag there. Usually not more than 10-20USD and I can use it as a gift once back home.

Only once did I get something shipped. It was a rather big paper mache sculpture that I had shipped from Mexico to Germany in a giant wooden crate. It was expensive but worth it.

Generally, though, I'm not a big souvenir person. I take photos. But I don't buy knick-knacks.
January 22, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterTill
Maria, books. Well yes. Now there's a problem. However, that's usually a weight problem before it becomes a volume problem. If the stuff wasn't so bulky and fragile I could also see myself bringing more alcohol with me. For example, it is impossible to buy Martini Bianco in the US. You only get the Extra Dry version by the same company but they don't export the sweet vermouth to the US. So I usually bring a bottle of that along. It's not that it's expensive or whatever, it's just plain unavailable here. Pity! I have one of those styrofoam wine crates. The bottle gets wrapped in a plastic bag, then put in the wine crate.
January 22, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterTill
Yes books. I'm dangerous in a book store. Before the weight restrictions on carry-on bags, I would just carry it with me, and try to look like the bag was light weight!

To bring back wine and alcohol, I've read and heard that Rimowa luggage can handle such. I do not own their pieces, sadly, but it's an intriguing aspect. Plus Rimowa is much cheaper to purchase in Germany. Well, that's a practical souvenir - a nice carrier, and the bottles!
January 22, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterMaria
My next big trip will take me through France and I'm definitely planning to buy some wine. I picked up some "wine diapers" on Amazon and a Reisenthel tote that folds up into its own pouch -- a full-size tote, not their little shopper bags (which I also have and use frequently). With the wine my main bag will obviously have to be checked and I can carry on the tote and my day bag, if needed.

I live in a small place and tend to go for souvenirs that are either small (refrigerator magnets), useful (the occasional t-shirt), or consumable (alcohol, tea, etc.), but they add up, and if anyone has a birthday coming up I like to try to get them things they couldn't buy in the US or online. So after having to buy a tote bag during my last trip, I'm planning ahead this time. I'm still planning to go out with extra space in my bag.
January 22, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterCarrie
My souvenirs have generally been calorie-dense consumables (for colleagues) or miniatures (for my printer's tray which I have on the living room wall).
One of my favorite things in the printer's tray is a ceramic pipe stem my Dad found in the mud along the Thames. I don't know if it was legal for him to take, but it reminds me of the trips we've taken to London, together and separately.
January 22, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterHeather
It just so happens that the people I would buy souveniers for are also similar to me in both mindset and tshirt size. We believe that stuff, if not useful, is just dustcatchers. As such, my typical souveniers are usually bits and bobs that I have picked up because I forgot/needed the item while there (such as a dual voltage immersion heater while in Austria, the remainder of the packet of laundry soap from my sink washing - my friends love to try out nonUS products and do not mind that it is open), something consumable (a box of local tea bags, or a kilo of lose tea, can go a long way when divided at home), or something flat (postcard or stickers). Sometimes, I will be in a position where I need to get a new tshirt or where one is freely given to me. Then, those come home as souveniers, since I have plenty of tshirts at home. This happened a lot after the Rally to Restore Sanity in Washington, DC.

I have also considered, but not yet tried, the Little sticker books that you can make from your own photos. I think Moo cards sells them. I'd order them at the end of my trip and have them sent home. The stickers would have my best photos from the trip. Then everyone would get a sheet of stickers, and I could even write on the back and mail the sheets as post cards. My friends would get to see more than one photo (as happens with a post card) but could also use the stickers for whatever odd purpose it is that they are always using stickers.
January 23, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterLittle J
We / I don't buy souvenirs for others.
I will stock up at Boots and Marks & Spencer for myself, but those are places I always shopped at before I emigrated to Canada.
I leave some room in my bag for shopping and books, DEFINITELY books, those I generally buy at the airport 2 or 3 for 1 sales! I did make a pact with myself last trip......I must realise that as I do buy items (usually clothes), I do not need to pack too much for the trip.
My husband invariably buys tee shirts.
Years ago we did break the bank when my husband laid eyes on a rather superb collectible chess set, last one left. He had to have it and no way could we have traipsed around the UK and France with it, too big, too heavy! The shop arranged for it to be shipped to our home and as we were travelling for five weeks, we chose the slow and cheap method (which took eight weeks. We did have to pay quite a bit of duty on it at the Post Office. It now collects dust in the library/living room!


There are rare times when I don't buy anything other than toiletries, which I use during the trip anyway.
This year I am going to Spain (three weeks), the middle week will be me taking my mum to England for a week, she rarely shops now and as I need to stick to her like glue, I won't have time.
January 23, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterPaula S
Getting the "stuff" home isn't my problem, I either have it shipped (if it has size and value) or I buy a piece of cheap/disposable luggage and check it on the homeward leg. My problem is how you manage the "stuff" while you are touring, I once was given a beautiful Barong Tagalog on the first outbound leg of a trip through Asia by a close and dear relative. It weighed little and took very little space but was fragile. Protecting that single item drove me to distraction over the next nine weeks.
I now try (and frequently fail) to cleave to the old caver's dictum, take nothing but pictures, leave nothing but footprints. As I've aged, the memories become more dear than any of the treasures that I've bought (especially since I've begun to run out of space at home). I try to bring home only one small item to use as a touchstone for the experience. I find, oddly enough, that things that are strongly scented, like spices, are the most evocative for me.
BTW, the Barong is the answer to the how to onebag formal wear for men. You will never have to look like "just another penguin" and it is the most comfortable "monkey suit" that you can wear.
January 23, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterAirport Runner
I stopped buying souvenirs years ago. I found they just collected dust.

I also found myself lacking in both writing in my journal and taking photos. I guess I get so wrapped up in the experience I forget.

So, years ago, I started buying postcards. Yes, some I sent home, but most were for my benefit. I would write my journal on the back of the post card. So, let's say I bought one of the Eiffel Tower. Well, on the back of the card, I'd write the day and date and what I did that day or part of that day. . In a sense, it's a low tech photo journal.

These souvenirs take up practically no space, weigh very little, and give me great memories.

I used to buy books especially for long flights home...but now between my Kindle and IPod, I only buy a book if it's something I really want and can't find it at home.
January 23, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterFrank II
The ability to bring home souvenirs is one of the reasons I "one-bag' If there is something that I feel would make a good souvenir, then I have the space for it. What qualifies as a good souvenir though is judged against what is just "stuff" vs a significant memorial item. Sometimes is is a print from a local artist in Europe. Other times it is a quarter sized broken piece of a circuit board found in a ditch in an impoverished village in Central America. Many times it is just memories and photos. One-bagging creates options for me, not limits them.
January 23, 2011 | Unregistered Commenterstevenshytle
As a teen in Europe I watched several other UCLA college students cart around huge bags of stuff, boxes of stuff, shoulder bags of stuff... you get the idea. . I bought a large bottle of perfume (one which had been discontinued and I'd happily found at a shop in Florence). That was the only 'souvenir' I had for a summer's worth of European college study in Theatre Architecture and History. I had the smallest bag of the whole group and had to wait on the rest of them at every stop (we were a group of 17). I carted around half of my very small suitcase empty JUST SO I could shop at a store in Piccadilly Circus called Dark They Were And Golden Eyed, which in the '70's was the largest science fiction bookstore in the world. London, of course, was our last stop, and I'd planned on the stop for months..

I've never done it since. The books were worth it, but heavy! Just getting it from Customs at LAX to another terminal for my flight to PHX and then on to DTW (for a family gathering) was nearly the end of my back!

Other than that, my only other 'souvenirs' of my first trip (on my own) to Europe were: one small Swiss Army penknife, good for cutting up food as we traveled about, a set of Mary Quant watercolor eyeshadows (which I wore continuously until they were gone), and a pair of red wool socks which kept my feet from freezing in Switzerland. That was it. What else did I need? Those socks lasted until the late "90's, and every time I wore them I thought of Lausanne. I still have the penknife. I even have some of the books (although I've given many of them away to good friends as gifts over the years).

Oh. I forgot - I also bought at shirt at a hotel in Amsterdam. I wore that out, too. I also wore it IN Amsterdam, so I guess that wasn't really a souvenir, but actual clothing.

That trip was over 30 years ago, and I haven't changed much. I travel smaller now that I did then (although my clothes are no longer the same size... boo... Why go somewhere and buy tacky things to commemorate it, since most of that 'stuff; isn't even locally produced and comes with the ubiquitous 'made in China' label? Then again, if more people traveled the way I do, Goodwill, Sally Ann, and the local thrift stores wouldn't have items to sell...
January 23, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterAlana
One other thing I do buy on trips to London: Taylors of Harrogate tea, which for me is culinary necessity, not a souvenir. I know of two stores in Seattle which sell it, and I am a tea drinker when I don't have a bottle of Diet Dr. Pepper in my hand. I have been known to fill my carryon with Taylors' Darjeeling and China Rose coming home, but what's worse is that I actually carry the makings of five cups' worth of loose leaves (and a teaball) on the plane TO England, just so I can have my favorite tea in transit, whcih is kind of like carrying coals to Newcastle....
January 23, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterAlana
<<I've read and heard that Rimowa luggage can handle such. I do not own their pieces, sadly, but it's an intriguing aspect. Plus Rimowa is much cheaper to purchase in Germany.>>

Alas, for their most affordable line, Salsa, which is NOT cheap, it also does not do well with the heavy-handed tactics of current baggage handling. We have had two of their 29-inch cases, one has a dent, the other developed a split, and has been donated, and replaced by an ultralightweight Antler. So, if and when we get to Germany...we won't be buying more Rimowa, not to mention I'd be taking my Redoxx Air Boss, or perhaps my Osprey Porter 46.
January 23, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterAlan B
Thanks to Little J's mention of MOO, I've now a stickerbook ordered. This could be the start of a new Christmas tradition :-)

I also like Frank II's post card journal suggestion. I have some trips well documented in a journal and some not at all. I tend to buy post cards anyway, so combined with a slip-in photo journal, I think I want to try it.
January 23, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterBetsey
We buy very little in the way of stuff to bring home. Sharon is a fabric artist so there is always something made of cloth or cloth itself in the case of Mador's of Glasgow. I usually buy some pins. We buy small gifts for the two grandkids and our three brothers and sisters. Something representative of the countries we've been in. Sharon's folks are still alive so we get them something. We also have an afternoon ritual while travelling of having some wine or beer and writing postcards to friends and relatives.

We don't buy t-shirts anymore because we have enough to last us well into the next life, but once in a while we'll buy an article of clothing representative of a country such as a man's barong shirt in the Philippines, or jummy caps in Scotland.

The grands also get some coins and we always bring back a piece of currency for the lady who owns the local pub as she has a collection, thanks to us.

I doubt that I have more than a few ounces more coming home than going unless I'm helping carry fabric home. Sharon, on the other hand, makes up quite well for the smallness of her clothes in relationship to mine.
January 23, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterMonte
Alan B - excellent point! Perhaps if I could afford a Rimowa and a few bottles of excellent wine to cart back...I could then afford to hire a private plane instead! Yes, I've read that expensive luggage, even of high standards, can not always survive the baggage handler. Who themselves are probably overworked by lifting all those over-weight all day long each day. In fact, I believe the "dents" on Rimowa pieces are meant to add character? Perhaps that was in one of their ads? :)
January 23, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterMaria
On the Rimowa. The Salsa is the "plastic" line. It is a foam like flexible plastic material poly-something. The line they are famous for is the Topas line. That's the stuff made of aluminum. Lighter and sturdier than Zero Halliburton. The one I bought, I bought precisely to haul fragile items like wine or artworks between Germany and the US. I never had anything break in it.

The thing with the dents is a nice reframing idea from the PR department. But you know what? It's quite true. Even after a single trip or two the case will not look new anymore but it will still look spectacular. Imagine the young Liz Taylor with messy hair. :D

That said, a case like the Samsonite Oyster or Delsey New Volume, which are their most simple and lightest hard shell cases made from ABS with a hard frame (important), will protect the contents just as well as the Rimowas and cost 1/5th. They will also not attract as much attention as the Rimowa. I get mine opened at least 50/50. And not always is there a note in there that it was opened. I have gone as far as putting a note in there saying that I have a list of the contents, photos of the contents and that they please put a note in there when they opened it. This has helped somewhat but not always.

I also just remembered that I saw a nifty little invention for transporting wine bottles. It's an inflatable sleeve, like an air mattress, that goes around the bottle. Smart idea. Light and doesn't take much room on the way there.

Wine and watches are one of the top items to bring back to the US (specifically from Europe but possibly also from other countries). The import tax on wine is minimal. You have to declare everything over one litre but up to six bottles most agents will just wave you through. Too much hassle for $10 or so collected. The watches you can declare also. Though mostly they never notice. If you do declare, the duties are in the range of less than $100 even on a $5000 watch. You can get a tax refund when you take the item outside of the EU. On such an expensive piece the mostly 19% of VAT they add in Europe are obviously quite a lot of money. More than $700. A watch will also not weigh you down so much. ;)

The VAT on art is lower than on normal products in EU countries. Around 7% VAT. There is no import duty on art when you bring it into the US.
January 24, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterTill
Like others on the board, I use postcards as souvenirs. My husband is also a pretty good photographer so we spend a day and a night taking interesting pictures of town and enhance them once we get home. There's a whole wall in our house of nothing but photos we took on our different vacations.

I've also been collecting refrigerator magnets. They're a bit heavier than postcards but you can find some quirky ones out there; my favorite being a cartoon cow from the Pyengana Dairy Farm in Tasmania. :)
January 24, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterJenny
I woulnd't mind having a fancy Rimowa - just to know it's there if need be! Thank you for the specifics Till.

I found that I'd buy postcards for other people and keep the best ones for myself (well, technically I'd buy doubles so I can keep some too) and store them in my photo album. But I also copy "travel photos" from various websites of my favourite cities and save them on the computer to glance at too.
January 24, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterMaria
On my latest euro trip, I went one bag there. While in Belgium, I picked up 2 cases of beer that's unavailable in the US. Solution? I bought a cheap hard case suitcase, bubble wrap and checked it free due to the class of travel. 70 kilograms normally would have triggered a overweight baggage fee!

Averaged over the two trips, 1.5 bag travel! So maybe not one bag travel :)
January 24, 2011 | Unregistered Commenterajiw
If domestic, I will carry a flat rate mailer, plastic/tyvek envelope, and postage. I had thought about packing one but didn't, wound up squirreling away a few toiletries that didn't fit in the 3-1-1, and then found out that the business resorts all wanted an extra $5-10 for sending it on top of the postage. A USPS mailer envelope would have taken care of that.
January 25, 2011 | Unregistered Commenterreeder
The type of things I normally would bring home as souvenirs (art, teas, and even some special liquors) I can now buy on the internet so I don't need to lug them back. In Europe, we use to always bring back wine but it is to much a pain now we solved that by drinking LOTS when we are there.

My buying habits for souvenirs has completely changed overseas. I would always buy items made in the country I was touring to support locals. During the last 5 years I've had difficulty doing this: for example, in my recent tours to Ireland and Scotland I found most things were made in China. I had to work to find something made in the country! I now buy art post cards and cards by local artists when I tour overseas. Most of our friends are now into minimalism and don't expect anything more than postcards/cards.

My typical souvenirs tend to be small and useful: I collect scarves and local jewelry which turns my black travel wardrobe into something fun as I travel. I leave room specifically for these items.

Every once in a while I find a really unique kitchen item that I end up bringing back - but that is why I also leave room in my suitcase. I also enjoy buying art items and papers. Both don't take much space and are not too heavy.

As with others, I've shipped unexpected purchases. I also love books, but most now can be bought on the internet - I write down the ISBN or if I really don't think I can find them (i.e. a book in a foreign language) I buy and ship home. I've bought other items that shipped such as a custom ladies formal kilt I had made in Scotland. So I have a budget for shipping home on trips to Europe.
January 25, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterMaggie
In the U.S. the post office flat rate boxes are cheaper than a checked bag.

On a trip to Hawaii on business I was given gifts by the company I was helping and I was asked to shop for some items for another project we were working on back home. I shipped everything except the Chinese hats (for a display) back in three flat rate boxes. The hats were my second carry on item.

When traveling outside the US I'm usually carrying things for people from here that they can't get. They pay for the checked bag going and coming I don't usually have costs. So I fill that empty bag with souvenirs and gifts.
January 25, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterK-eM
As a first time OBOW traveler (this fall), I have been researching travel forums for tips & tricks on packing - I am so glad to have found this site- and this post with your comments have been the single most helpful thing online I've read so far in weeks! THANK YOU!

My husband and I are like Maggie in that we try to buy handmade items from local people in whatever country we are in- it can be a challenge. This fall, we're going to Italy & Germany (stopping along the way somewhere in between) and I've committed to a carry-on. I'm off to finish reading this entire site, but wanted to let you all know (if you revisit this post) your tips will certainly help us newbies with a hassle free packing/hauling vacation.
February 16, 2011 | Unregistered Commenterdenise:)
My solution is to find a cardboard box, and check that as luggage. It's perfectly acceptable. Wine is shipped in cardboard all the time, if that's what you're interested in bringing back. I too have switched to buying local only, it's more fun to find and support local artists. I only buy Chinese things when I'm in China, although it is hard, even in Vietnam a lot of stuff(clothing in particular) is made in China.
February 17, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterLucy

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Post:
 
All HTML will be escaped. Hyperlinks will be created for URLs automatically.